Study Compares Modern Greenland to the 1930s as Viewed Through the Lens of Rockwell Kent

“I don't want petty self-expression; I want the elemental, infinite thing; I want to paint the rhythm of eternity.” — Rockwell Kent

Rockwell Kent isn’t exactly a household name today. But in the first half of the 20th century, the New York-born Kent was the definition of a Renaissance Man: painter, illustrator, author and adventurer would have been some of the occupations to appear on his CV.

A transcendentalist in the mold of Emerson and Thoreau, Kent had a particular fondness for the cold, remote corners of the world, traveling to such far-flung places as Alaska, Tierra del Fuego and Greenland.

  Sisimiut Harbor, Greenland, as photographed by Denis Defibaugh, left, and Rockwell Kent in the 1930s (courtesy Plattsburgh State Art Museum, SUNY Plattsburgh, USA, Rockwell Kent Collection, bequest of Sally Kent Gorton. All rights reserved.).

Sisimiut Harbor, Greenland, as photographed by Denis Defibaugh, left, and Rockwell Kent in the 1930s (courtesy Plattsburgh State Art Museum, SUNY Plattsburgh, USA, Rockwell Kent Collection, bequest of Sally Kent Gorton. All rights reserved.).

It was in 1930s Greenland where Kent produced a series of photographs—turned into lantern slides that now reside in the Plattsburgh State Art Museum in New York—that would eventually inspire photographer Denis Defibaugh to follow the artist nearly 90 years later. Defibaugh is the principal investigator on a National Science Foundation-funded project for a comparative study of Greenland then and now—culturally, historically, environmentally and otherwise.

Defibaugh_Greenland_Illorsuit_c_3_40.jpg
  Denis Defibaugh in Greenland, above, and the town of Illorsuit in winter. Photo credits: Denis Defibaugh.

Denis Defibaugh in Greenland, above, and the town of Illorsuit in winter. Photo credits: Denis Defibaugh.

“I just thought [the slides] were so beautiful; this was something I could actually wrap my interests around,” explains Defibaugh, a tenured professor at Rochester Institute of Technology who has also traveled extensively, conducting workshops and holding solo exhibits around the world.

A Participant in History

“For an American to be in Greenland in that era was just unheard of, and it wasn’t easy for [Kent] to get into Greenland,” notes Defibaugh. In fact, Kent’s first foray to Greenland in 1929 was more in the mold of Ernest Shackleton’s Endurance expedition, the most famous tale of survival to emerge from the Heroic Age of Antarctic Exploration. In the Greenland version, a storm wrecked Kent’s ship while moored in a fjord, forcing him to hike to a nearby town for help. He eventually found aid in the small village of Narsaq.

  Rockwell Kent

Rockwell Kent

  Greenland Air Mail stamps, 1932, as designed by Kent.

Greenland Air Mail stamps, 1932, as designed by Kent.

“That was his first interaction with Greenlanders, and he became infatuated with the people,” Defibaugh says.

Kent wasn’t just a bystander to history. This was 1930s Greenland, and its people were under Danish control, with all of the social and political upheavals typically associated with the colonial rule of indigenous people.

“Kent was highly critical of Danish policies in Greenland, evidenced in both his writings and in the absence of colonial presence in his paintings,” says Susan Vanek, a doctoral student in anthropology at Binghamton University who is a co-PI on the project. “His views reflected his background and political opinions, which adds to an understanding of 1930s Greenland that has largely been told from the perspective of the Danish colonial authorities.”

That Kent chose to live in some of the smaller town and villages, such as Illorsuit, also provides a unique perspective.

“Kent was also special because he chose to settle for a long period of time in one small community. He tried to live as part of that community and participate in local practices, such as the whale hunt and dog sledding, unlike other travelers and explorers who often were more interested in Greenland as an ‘exotic’ or ‘unexplored’ place,” adds Jette Rygaard, another co-PI on the team and an associate professor at the University of Greenland who has conducted research there for 25 years.

Participants of Modern Life

Since 2016, various members of the team have primarily visited four towns where Kent spent most of his years in Greenland—Illorsuit, Uummannaq, Sisimiut and Nuuk.

Defibaugh is in the midst of culling through photographs, many taken from similar vantage points or themes that appeared in Kent’s photographs and paintings, for a couple of planned books and upcoming exhibitions.

  Illorsuit Sound diptych by Kent 1932, left, and Defibaugh 2016

Illorsuit Sound diptych by Kent 1932, left, and Defibaugh 2016

“There were three things that Kent addressed in his photographs and in his paintings,” Defibaugh says, “the primal landscape, the landscape in relationship to people and settlements, and then people—he would paint people, photograph people. His paintings that incorporated people were primarily to express scale and to show a sense of place and people in the environment.”

The people in the local communities were also a major focus of the three-year field project. The team made public presentations about their work, reintroducing Kent’s images of their country to a new generation, particularly to the local youths who also participated in photography workshops. Photo exhibitions of work by both Kent and the students were hugely popular, according to Vanek.

“Even if people did not know or remember Kent, they remembered the people and places pictured in his works,” she says.

letter.jpg

The researchers also did some deep dives into local archival collections. For instance, Rygaard examined letters (like the one at left) at the Ilulissat Museum from the famous Danish Arctic explorer Knud Rasmussen to his daughter Hanne, warning her about Rockwell Kent.

“To have letters like that in your hand is really a unique experience, especially in our time of e-mails and texts,” she says.

 

 

 

Value of Comparative Study

Vanek and Rygaard just completed their final round of field work where they revisited many of the communities and schools. The students had produced about 10,000 photos during the course of the project, some of which will appear in a published book featuring their work.

“Each student will receive a copy of the book when it is produced, and a number of people we have talked to about the book are impressed that all the proceeds from any sales of the book will go to children’s charity in Greenland,” Rygaard says.

  Sisimiut Museum exhibition opening of photographs by Defibaugh and Kent. Photo credit: Denis Defibaugh

Sisimiut Museum exhibition opening of photographs by Defibaugh and Kent. Photo credit: Denis Defibaugh

Comparative studies, like the Rockwell Kent project, provide a variety of insights, according to Vanek.

“On one level, they allow us to examine how people see their pasts and how they translate that into understandings of their lives today and how they envision their futures,” she explains. “By working with individuals from different age ranges, genders, and social groups, we can also move toward an understanding of the past that is more nuanced—a past that [is] constructed in multiple ways by various individuals and groups in the present, highlighting their concerns today.”

  Group portrait in Illorsuit of kids in the photo workshop. From row: Uiloriaq M. Jerimiassen, Majka Qvist, Mona Korneliussen, Francis Korneliussen, Frederik Malakiassen and Najannguaq Malakiassen. Back row: Steffen Jerimiassen-Motzfeld, Axel Jerimiassen, Angerlannguaq Korneliussen, Kyra Kryniski, Tonja Korneliussen and Susan Vanek. Photo credit: Denis Defibaugh.

Group portrait in Illorsuit of kids in the photo workshop. From row: Uiloriaq M. Jerimiassen, Majka Qvist, Mona Korneliussen, Francis Korneliussen, Frederik Malakiassen and Najannguaq Malakiassen. Back row: Steffen Jerimiassen-Motzfeld, Axel Jerimiassen, Angerlannguaq Korneliussen, Kyra Kryniski, Tonja Korneliussen and Susan Vanek. Photo credit: Denis Defibaugh.

The insights also serve as a catalyst to discuss the contemporary issues facing the communities, according to Vanek, such as population movements from smaller villages to larger towns, as well as the lack of education and employment opportunities.

“One of the saddest things for me is that the settlements are kind of going away,” Defibaugh says. “The hunting culture that was a big part of Greenland when Kent was there, in terms of hunting for whales, walrus and seals—using seal skins as a way to create income—has very much been depleted. Not that there aren’t plenty of seals but there’s no market for the seals anymore”

Vanek says that the seismic changes underway today are part of larger processes that were already underway in the 1930s.

“Some towns established during the colonial period were becoming more prosperous while others were shrinking; the fishing industry was beginning to outpace marine mammal products in economic importance; [and] the population was growing and numerous other changes were taking place,” she notes. “So, when talking about challenges faced by communities today, it is important to remember there were significant changes and transitions going on in the early 20th century as well, some of which continue today.”

 

 

Grass, Environmental Change, Farming & Human Ecodynamics

Grass probably isn’t the first thing that comes to mind when thinking about the foundations of Icelandic culture and society. But the humble blade of grass has played an incredibly important role in Iceland since the early days of settlement.

Endangered Archaeology: Climate Change May Swallow History

When John Darwent returned to a remote corner of northwestern Greenland in 2012 to search for the remains of a paleo-Inuit culture that had occupied the area millennia ago, he found the site dramatically changed.

Mapping Community Exposure to Coastal Hazards in Alaska

Communities along the far northern coastlines of Alaska are witnessing some of the highest erosion rates in the world. Less and less sea ice cover results in the direct exposure of coastal soils to the destructive blunt force of powerful wave energy.

Economic Inequality & Environmental Change in Medieval Iceland

During the middle ages, Iceland’s recently settled landscape saw many changes. Kathryn Catlin, a doctoral candidate at Northwestern University’s Anthropology Department, is digging in Iceland’s soil for clues to the impacts of these changes.

Scenes from Smithsonian's Arctic Spring Festival

Scenes from Smithsonian's Arctic Spring Festival

Field Notes frequent contributor Alicia Clarke checked out the Arctic Spring Festival last weekend and offered this snapshot of the event. Check out our photos here!

Gender, Environment and Change in the Arctic

Gender, Environment and Change in the Arctic

Indigenous communities in the Arctic are facing a lot of pressure. The region is warming twice as fast as other parts of the world, with significant impacts to the Arctic ecosystem.

Tradition & Science: The Yakutat Seal Camps Project

Tradition & Science: The Yakutat Seal Camps Project

Dr. Aron Crowell, Alaska Director of the Smithsonian Arctic Studies Center, is contributing to the debate with his own anthropological findings from a research project in Alaska that’s searching for (and finding) archaeological sites using oral history as a guide.

Recap: Joint Science Education Project 2014

Recap: Joint Science Education Project 2014

Earlier this summer, Lynn Foshee Reed, organizer of Arctic Science Education Week, sent us a recap of the Joint Science Education Project (JSEP) 2014.

Oil, Conservation & Hunting Rights in the Chukchi Sea

Oil, Conservation & Hunting Rights in the Chukchi Sea

At first blush, there is not a lot in common between eider ducks and increased oil production off the coast of Alaska’s Chukchi Sea. But look a little deeper and you’ll discover that the researchers’ work on water birds is a key component in engaging Native communities in northern Alaska.

GrIT Update: Mission Accomplished

The GrIT operations team is back in Thule! After dealing with mechanical issues, traveling many hundreds of miles, and experiencing a range of weather, the team reached Thule this week.

Exploring Fisheries Management and Livelihoods in Iceland

Strong fisheries coupled with Iceland's unique fisheries management system makes it a perfect place to explore questions of how people, their families, interests and finances are all connected to fishing and management strategies.

Retaining teachers in the Alaskan bush

There’s no question that life is different in the Alaskan bush. Challenging as the remoteness and weather conditions in a Native community may be, these qualities often initially draw teachers to rural Alaska. Unfortunately, these same qualities often send them packing for urban centers.

Promoting Diversity in Science

Head north into the Arctic and you’ll find a self-selected crew of researchers devoting their field seasons to uncovering the mysteries and facts of the region. Efforts are afoot to diversify the Arctic research community, and at the helm is Linda Hayden.

Pilot Study Explores Tlingit Cairns in Southeast Alaska

For many, (semi) retirement is a chance to kick back and relax. But for archeologist Bill Hunt, retirement gave him the opportunity to delve in to unexplored areas of southeast Alaska and uncover the secrets behind manmade rock piles called cairns that dot the landscape.

Ancient Adaptation & Climate Change in the Aleutian Islands

The Islands of the Four Mountains in Alaska’s central Aleutians are about as inhospitable an environment as a person can imagine. Bad weather reigns, the wind and rain conspiring to create the perfect conditions for hypothermia.

Documentary Explores Ancient Tlingit Rock Formations

Parts of south Alaska’s inland, alpine landscape are dotted with mounds of artificially stacked rocks that are closely tied to Tlingit culture. These structures, known as rock cairns, are the focus of Cairns Uncovered, a soon-to-be-released documentary.

Reconstructing ancient populations in Alaska

Shelby Anderson spends most summers in the Alaskan bush digging up clues about the peoples who lived there more than 1,000 years ago. Anderson’s work focuses on northwest Alaska’s hunter-gatherer societies.